2 in, wish I had more

r/buttsharpies

Is 3 ok for starters??

r/buttsharpies

Only 1 . She needs to stretch.

r/buttsharpies

my first time! is 3 enough or you think i can handle four ?! [OC]

r/buttsharpies

Two to the hilt in my cute butthole

r/buttsharpies

first attempt (f)

r/buttsharpies

So unassuming yet so distracting (f)

r/buttsharpies

First try! Can't wait to do more! [OC]

r/buttsharpies

Sharpie anyone?

r/buttsharpies

She really wanted to be part of this sub, just gotta start off slow [oc]

r/buttsharpies

Managed to get 2 on my second day doing this. Was a challenge cause my ass is so tight. Shall I keep going?

r/buttsharpies

How else would you put two pens in your rear pocket?

r/buttsharpies

It’s been a long time since I’ve “played” with sharpies